Alligator Alcatraz Disaster

The proposed “Alligator Alcatraz” detention center in the Everglades is a disaster in the making for Collier County and Florida. Governor DeSantis’s claim of “emergency powers” to justify this project is a fabrication, designed to bypass public scrutiny and environmental protections. No genuine emergency exists that warrants building a massive detention facility in one of America’s most fragile ecosystems.   

Equally troubling is the refusal of Collier County Commissioners Rick LoCastro and Chris Hall to oppose the project. Despite repeated requests from residents, both have stated that Collier County has “no interest” and will not go on record against the facility - even though it sits within our county’s borders and threatens our community’s well-being. Leadership means standing up for your constituents, not hiding behind jurisdictional technicalities. 

The negative effects of “Alligator Alcatraz” are staggering. Economically, detaining up to 5,000 immigrants would strip Florida of over $12 million in annual tax revenue, worsen labor shortages in critical industries like agriculture and construction, and slash local consumer spending by $147 million each year. The ripple effect could cost our economy up to $300 million annually. Environmentally, the project will generate sewage, consume vast amounts of water, and produce light pollution - endangering wildlife and violating the sanctity of land sacred to the Miccosukee and Seminole peoples. Socially, it will tear families apart, worsen mental health, and undermine the fabric of our communities. 

Collier County’s elected officials must find the courage to oppose this reckless plan and defend our environment, economy, and values. Silence is complicity.