Woodworth, Sommerfeld Chosen to Lead Marco Island City Council

Posted
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Marco Island’s newly seated City Council elected Rick Woodworth chair and Teri Sommerfeld vice chair at its November 16 meeting, placing two first-time councilors in leadership roles as members addressed utility rates, floodplain regulations, coastal protection and public safety.

Woodworth, Sommerfeld and Dennis Bartolucci took their oaths of office before joining returning Councilors Stephen Gray, Tamara Goehler, Deb Henry and Bonita Schwan on the dais. The Council also advanced a comprehensive water and sewer rate study, supported state funding requests for advanced wastewater treatment and public records software, and approved Sand Dollar Island berm repairs after an extended discussion about the project’s environmental effects and long-term approach.

New Council Selects Its Leaders

After Gray declined a nomination for chair, Woodworth and Bartolucci were nominated. Woodworth was elected 6–1, receiving support from every councilor except himself. He voted for Bartolucci, whom he had nominated.

Sommerfeld was elected vice chair 4–3, with support from Gray, Goehler, Schwan and Henry. Sommerfeld, Bartolucci and Woodworth voted for Bartolucci, the other nominee.

After taking the chair, Woodworth thanked voters and emphasized that the Council would represent the entire island.

Tennis Players Describe Unsafe Courts

Several residents urged the Council to address deteriorating tennis courts at the Marco Island Racquet Center, describing closed courts, raised lines, uneven surfaces and injuries.

One longtime player said two courts had been unusable for extended periods and that raised lines on other courts created tripping hazards. Another described a recent fall that prompted an ambulance response and left her with multiple injuries.

Speakers questioned why pickleball improvements had moved forward while basic tennis court maintenance remained unresolved. They also expressed concern about the possibility of losing additional tennis courts to pickleball.

Floodplain Changes Could Affect Renovations

The Council unanimously advanced two floodplain-related ordinances on first reading, including changes affecting homeowners planning renovations.

Proposed Ordinance 26-10 would stop the City from automatically adding together improvement and repair costs over a rolling 12-month period. A separate renovation would no longer count against a later project simply because both occur within that period. Costs belonging to one overall renovation would still be evaluated together.

However, certain storm protection and energy efficiency upgrades, including impact windows, shutters and insulation, would lose local exclusions and count toward the “50% rule.”

Under that rule, renovations costing at least half the building’s market value, excluding land, trigger current flood-resistant construction requirements. Older homes in the floodplain may have been built under less stringent standards. Reaching the threshold can require bringing the home into compliance with current flood requirements, potentially including raising it to the required elevation. 

Floodplain Coordinator Malek Hall said aligning City regulations with state guidance also helps maintain the City’s Class Five rating under the Community Rating System, which he said provides a 25% flood insurance premium discount. 

Companion Ordinance 26-11 would clarify related appeals and rebuilding provisions. Both require a second reading before final adoption.

Utility Study Will Examine Rates and Who Pays

The Council unanimously approved the scope of a comprehensive water and sewer utility rate study, adding an early workshop so councilors can discuss policy priorities before the consultant completes substantial work.

Water and Sewer General Manager Jeff Poteet said the utility’s rate structure has remained unchanged since 2006 and rates have not increased since 2017. Meanwhile, operating costs have risen, and the utility faces major investments in aging infrastructure, treatment facilities, and regulatory compliance.

The study will examine whether revenues can meet current and future obligations, whether costs are appropriately allocated among customer classes, and how fixed charges, usage rates, and conservation incentives should be structured. It will also cover reclaimed water and other utility charges.

Poteet said the goal is an independent analysis without a predetermined outcome. Council workshops will allow members to provide policy direction before final recommendations are developed. Reclaimed water pricing will present a policy question of its own, he said, because water once treated principally as a byproduct requiring disposal has become a commodity.

Approval of the study’s scope did not establish new rates. The next step is soliciting proposals from qualified consultants.

Council Urges Prompt Action on Wastewater Treatment

The Council approved requests for state funding to cover half the estimated cost of each of two initiatives: $500,000 for the approximately $1 million first phase of advanced wastewater treatment, or AWT, and $65,000 for public records management software estimated to cost $130,000. 

Bartolucci and Goehler urged prompt action on AWT, emphasizing that seeking state funding should not delay the project. City Manager Dr. Casey Lucius confirmed that the initial engineering, design, and permitting work is already budgeted for fiscal 2027 and would proceed without waiting for state funding. Any appropriation would reimburse eligible costs.

The software would help staff handle increasingly complex records requests involving text messages, social media communications, and AI-generated documents as well as emails. Lucius said much of that work is performed manually. Unlike AWT, the software is not budgeted, and the City would await a state funding commitment before proceeding.

The Council approved the funding requests 6-1, with Sommerfeld opposed.

Berm Repairs Approved, Broader Review Requested

An item initially placed on the consent agenda generated approximately 45 minutes of discussion before the Council unanimously approved $198,500 to repair the Tigertail Lagoon/Sand Dollar Island berm damaged by October king tides. The consent agenda groups routine items for approval in a single vote without separate discussion, but Schwan requested that this item be removed for review.

The repairs will be funded by the Hideaway Beach Tax District rather than the City’s general fund or an islandwide assessment.

Public Works Director Justin Martin said the berm protects northwestern Marco Island and maintains tidal flow into Tigertail Lagoon. Sommerfeld questioned the long-term effectiveness of repeatedly replacing sand and raised concerns about water quality, seagrass, mangroves and wildlife. Schwan sought additional advisory committee review.

Staff emphasized that the project was already permitted and that repairs needed to proceed before shorebird nesting season begins February 15.

The Council approved the expenditure and separately agreed to an informational review involving the Beach and Coastal Resources Advisory Committee and the tax district, with findings and any recommendations returning to the Council.

E-Bike Discussion Draws Calls for Enforcement 

Schwan renewed calls to examine e-bike safety, citing the recent City survey in which 61% of respondents reported being dissatisfied or very dissatisfied with the issue.

She presented research reporting a 760% increase in emergency department visits associated with e-bike injuries between January 2023 and July 2026. Those figures were not specific to Marco Island.

Several residents questioned the study’s methods and whether national statistics accurately reflect local conditions. Speakers urged stronger enforcement of existing rules, education, and improved visibility before additional restrictions.

Woodworth agreed that education and enforcement should precede additional ordinances and said he wanted a better understanding of local conditions before supporting more restrictions.

Woodworth Proposes Changes to Development Review, Landscaping and Financial Planning

Chair Woodworth presented four proposals addressing development oversight, landscaping choices, financial review, and infrastructure planning.

Six councilors backed Woodworth’s proposal to have City Attorney Alan Gabriel draft an amendment restoring the Council’s final approval authority over all site development plans. Ordinance 21-10 transferred that authority to the Planning Board in 2021; previously, the board made recommendations and the Council decided whether to approve the plans. Woodworth suggested placing minor projects on the consent agenda, allowing councilors to request separate discussion when needed. The amendment would return to the Council for consideration. Henry was the only councilor to oppose the drafting request.  

Six councilors also backed Woodworth’s request to draft landscaping amendments allowing homeowners greater flexibility to choose Florida-friendly ground cover instead of mandated turf grass. Woodworth said the changes could reduce fertilizer use and overwatering that contribute to canal pollution. Henry opposed the request. 

Woodworth proposed renaming the Audit Advisory Committee the Audit and Finance Committee to emphasize its broader financial role. Discussion clarified that its existing responsibilities already include financial performance, internal controls, and risk management. No name change was approved. Woodworth requested circulation of the committee’s responsibilities for further discussion.

Woodworth requested a comprehensive asset management plan to guide infrastructure maintenance, replacement, and spending priorities. Lucius said she could return with estimated costs for professional assistance if the Council agreed. No timeline was established. 

Lengthy Meeting Prompts Discussion of Format

As the meeting exceeded four hours, Bartolucci urged shorter agendas and additional meetings as needed. Woodworth proposed moving employee awards to separate celebrations and limiting proclamations. Other councilors favored retaining public recognition but streamlining presentations. The Council deferred the discussion.

Sommerfeld Proposes Rental Committee, Urges Survey Follow-Up

Vice Chair Sommerfeld proposed creating an ad hoc committee to help develop a short-term rental ordinance or registration program. She urged councilors to consider both property managers and residents affected by neighboring rentals when recommending committee members.

Although problems may have eased compared with previous years, Sommerfeld said some residents continue to experience disruptions. She emphasized that the committee should include people with firsthand experience managing rental properties and living beside them.

Sommerfeld agreed to prepare a white paper for a future meeting. No committee or registration program was established.

Sommerfeld also emphasized the importance of resident input in setting priorities, urging councilors to use the recent community survey results to guide the Council’s strategic plan and goals rather than set the findings aside after the initial presentation.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here