With Thanksgiving just around the corner, I thought it would be fun to take a look at what Thanksgiving dinner has cost American families over the years. Well, maybe “fun” depends on how closely you look at the grocery bill.
Inflation has a way of sneaking into our everyday lives, but sometimes we feel it most around the holidays. That got me thinking: Was Grandma really telling the truth when she said she could once feed the whole family for $20?
Few holidays are as uniquely American, or as cherished, as Thanksgiving. Families travel from near and far to gather around the table. Stories are told, football is on the TV, a few drinks may be poured, and somewhere in the kitchen a turkey is roasting in the oven.
The traditions may not have changed much, but the price certainly has. These days, feeding the family on Thanksgiving can feel like it costs an arm, a leg, and a turkey leg.
So, in the spirit of Thanksgiving, let’s turn back the clock, check Grandma’s math, and see just how much the cost of Thanksgiving has changed over the years.
All of the costs are based on feeding ten people. I will cover many of the common Thanksgiving dishes and the total cost over several decades. Let’s start in 1960.
Although the world may look a lot different now than in the 1960s, the Thanksgiving meal looks similar to what it did then. Thanksgiving is a great way to cover the impact of inflation over the years.
Turkey: The Star of the Thanksgiving Table
Let’s start with the star of the Thanksgiving table: the turkey.
Back in 1960, a Thanksgiving turkey cost just $3.83. Twenty years later, in 1980, that same centerpiece had climbed to $11.05. By 2000, the price had reached $15.65, and by 2020, it was up to $24.24. This year, the cost is expected to come in around $29.60.
Put it all together, and the price of the Thanksgiving turkey has risen roughly 672% since 1960.
So, while the recipe for Thanksgiving turkey may not have changed much over the years, the price certainly has. That $3.83 turkey from 1960 sounds almost unbelievable today. And we’re just getting started. After all, a turkey by itself doesn’t make a Thanksgiving dinner.
Mashed Potatoes: A Thanksgiving Favorite
Next up is one of my personal favorites: mashed potatoes. Whether you like them smooth and creamy, loaded with butter, or buried underneath a lake of gravy, it’s hard to imagine Thanksgiving without them.
In 1960, enough mashed potatoes to feed 10 people cost about $1.06. By 1980, the year I was born, the cost had climbed to $2.27. In 2000, it reached $4.58, and by 2020, it was $5.89. This year, the cost is expected to be around $6.90.
That works out to an increase of roughly 550% since 1960.
Apparently, the only thing growing faster than the pile of mashed potatoes on my Thanksgiving plate is the price of putting them there.
Stuffing: From Side Dish to Luxury Item?
Then we have another Thanksgiving staple: stuffing.
In 1960, enough stuffing to feed 10 people cost just 78 cents. By 1980, that had jumped to $2.86. In 2020, the cost had climbed to $6.54, and this year it is expected to reach a whopping $15.34.
That means the price of stuffing has increased an incredible 1,866% since 1960. Even more surprising, the price has risen about 134% just since 2020. The rising cost of ingredients, including eggs, has helped push the price higher.
At this point, Thanksgiving stuffing may officially qualify as a luxury item. Keep this up, and families may soon have to choose between stuffing the turkey and stuffing their 401(k).
All jokes aside, an increase of more than 100% in just a few years is a great example of how quickly inflation can change the price of something we rarely give much thought to.
Mac and Cheese: Comfort Food Comes at a Price
Now we come to another one of my favorites: mac and cheese. It may not appear on every Thanksgiving table, but in my book, there is always room for it.
In 1960, enough mac and cheese to feed 10 people cost about $3.00. By 1980, the price had climbed to $7.60. At the turn of the century, it had reached $15.74. By 2020, the cost was $22.38, and this year it is expected to come in around $24.06.
That represents an increase of more than 700% since 1960.
Apparently, there is nothing “cheesy” about the price increase. The good news is that after all these years, mac and cheese is still worth fighting over when the serving bowl makes its way around the table.
Pumpkin Pie: Save Room for Dessert
Of course, no Thanksgiving dinner is complete without dessert, and for generations the traditional favorite has been pumpkin pie.
In 1960, a pumpkin pie cost just 89 cents. By 1980, the price had risen to $2.66. In 2000, it reached $5.34, and during the pandemic year of 2020, it cost about $7.86. Interestingly, this year the estimated cost is actually lower, at around $6.68.
Even with that recent decline, the price of pumpkin pie has risen roughly 650% since 1960.
So maybe asking for that second slice isn’t completely out of the question. And after surviving the price of the turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, and mac and cheese, I think we’ve earned it.
Besides, everyone knows Thanksgiving calories don’t count. Inflation, unfortunately, does.
The Total Cost of Thanksgiving: Grandma Was Right
So, after working our way from the turkey to the pumpkin pie, it’s time to answer the question we started with: Was Grandma really telling the truth when she said she could feed the whole family for $20? As it turns out, Grandma was right. In 1960, the total cost of our Thanksgiving dinner was about $15.63 to feed 10 people. Today, feeding those same 10 people costs approximately $137.93, an increase of roughly 782%. If you walked into Thanksgiving dinner in 1960 with a $20 bill, you could pay for the entire meal and still have money left over. Today, that same $20 might cover the turkey, but you better hope someone else is bringing the sides. It’s a simple reminder of how powerful inflation can be over time. The turkey, mashed potatoes, stuffing, mac and cheese, and pumpkin pie haven’t changed all that much, but the number of dollars needed to put them on the table certainly has. Fortunately, the most important parts of Thanksgiving don’t come with a price tag: family, friends, laughter, traditions, and the memories made around the table. So, when Grandma starts telling everyone how cheap things were back in her day, maybe don’t roll your eyes this year. She has the receipts to prove it.
Happy Thanksgiving!
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here