Cynthia Corogin, with Premier Sotheby’s International Realty’s Marco Island office, has sold a $5.3 million, Gulf-to-Bay property with two deeded single-family homes on Casey Key. Located at 801-810 Casey Key Road in Nokomis, the private estate sits on 100 feet of beach frontage at some of the widest portions of the 8-mile island.
Charlotte Hedge of The Hedge Team with Premier Sotheby’s International Realty’s Sarasota office represented the seller; Cynthia Corogin, of the firm’s Marco Island office, brought the buyer. This is the highest sale, year-to-date on Casey Key.
The French Provincial main residence was designed by its previous owners and built by Frank Miller. Featuring five en-suite bedrooms, six baths and two half baths, the home’s open floor plan boasts a gourmet kitchen, private elevator and unobstructed Gulf views. Outdoor living is highlighted by a sundeck, al fresco kitchen, infinity pool and spa — all surrounded by lush, mature landscaping.
The charming two-bedroom, two-bath bayfront cottage is situated on 90 feet of the Intracoastal Waterway, with new seawall and boat dock. The property’s idyllic locale is convenient to the countless cultural offerings of Venice and Sarasota.
“It’s rare to find a Gulf-to-bay property that offers two homes on one parcel. This was a unique opportunity for a discerning buyer, who realized its exceptional value,” said Charlotte Hedge. Cynthia Corogin said, “My buyers were specifically looking for properties that were Gulf to Bay. They wanted beachfront, with plenty of land, and docking options for their boat, all on one property. Casey Key checked all of the boxes.”